How to Choose the Best DUI Lawyer in Michigan: What Actually Matters in OWI Defense

How to Choose a DUI or OWI Lawyer in Michigan

Quick Answer: What Should You Look for in a Michigan DUI Lawyer?

The best Michigan DUI or OWI lawyer for a particular case is not necessarily the attorney with the largest advertisement or the most aggressive marketing. Look for an attorney with substantial OWI-specific experience, a clear process for reviewing breath, blood and video evidence, knowledge of driver’s-license consequences, familiarity with the court handling the case and the ability to prepare for both negotiation and trial.

The right lawyer should explain the evidence, identify potential legal issues, discuss realistic options and answer questions without guaranteeing a particular result.

DUI Lawyer Selection at a Glance

Factor	What to Look For
Relevant experience	Regular handling of Michigan OWI, OWVI, High BAC and repeat-offense cases
Evidence knowledge	Understanding of breath, blood, video and field-sobriety evidence
Constitutional analysis	Careful review of the stop, detention, search, arrest, statements and warrants
Court familiarity	Experience in the court handling the case
License knowledge	Understanding of suspensions, restrictions, revocations, ignition interlock and implied consent
Preparation	A defined method for investigating, negotiating and preparing the case
Communication	Direct, realistic explanations and prompt responses

Michigan officially uses the term OWI—Operating While Intoxicated—although many people use “DUI” when searching for legal help. Michigan’s principal OWI statute is MCL 257.625.

---

How Do You Choose the Best DUI Lawyer for Your Michigan Case?

Choosing an OWI lawyer requires more than comparing websites, slogans or advertisements.

The attorney should be able to explain:

• What evidence must be reviewed

• What the prosecution must prove

• What legal and scientific issues may apply

• What happens in the court handling the case

• What driver’s-license consequences may arise

• What immediate deadlines or bond conditions require attention

• How the case will be prepared if negotiations do not produce an acceptable resolution

The best choice depends on the facts of the case, the attorney’s relevant experience and whether the client is comfortable with the proposed approach.

Critical takeaway: The most effective lawyer is not necessarily the one who talks the most. It may be the lawyer who asks the right questions and identifies weaknesses in the evidence early.

---

The Seven-Factor DUI Lawyer Evaluation

Use these seven factors when comparing Michigan OWI attorneys.

1. How Much OWI-Specific Experience Does the Lawyer Have?

Many criminal-defense attorneys accept drunk-driving cases. That does not necessarily mean OWI defense is a substantial part of their practice.

Ask whether the lawyer regularly handles:

• Michigan OWI cases

• Operating While Visibly Impaired cases

• High BAC or “Super Drunk” charges

• Drugged-driving allegations

• Repeat-offense OWI

• Felony third-offense OWI

• Implied-consent proceedings

• Breath- and blood-testing cases

OWI-specific experience matters because these cases combine criminal law, constitutional issues, scientific evidence and administrative driver’s-license consequences.

2. Does the Lawyer Understand OWI Evidence?

Michigan OWI cases may involve much more than a police officer’s written report.

Relevant evidence may include:

• Body-camera video

• Dash-camera video

• Dispatch recordings

• Witness statements

• Field-sobriety testing

• Preliminary breath testing

• Evidential breath-test records

• Blood-draw records

• Laboratory reports

• Medical records

• Police training and equipment records

• The timing of alcohol, medication or substance consumption

Ask the attorney how this evidence will be obtained, reviewed and compared with the allegations.

A lawyer should not assume that a chemical-test number or officer’s conclusion tells the complete story.

3. Does the Lawyer Have Experience in the Court Handling the Case?

Court familiarity can help an attorney explain local procedures, scheduling, bond conditions and what a client should expect at each hearing.

Fraiberg & Pernie regularly represents clients in district and circuit courts throughout Oakland, Wayne and Macomb Counties, including courts serving Bloomfield Hills, Birmingham, West Bloomfield, Troy, Rochester Hills, Novi, Royal Oak, Southfield, Farmington Hills, Ferndale, Detroit, Livonia, Canton, Plymouth, Westland, Warren, Sterling Heights, Shelby Township and Clinton Township.

Local experience does not guarantee a result. It can, however, help the attorney prepare the client for the procedures and requirements of the particular court.

4. Can the Lawyer Identify Constitutional and Procedural Issues?

An OWI investigation may raise questions such as:

• Did the officer have lawful grounds for the traffic stop?

• Was the detention extended without proper justification?

• Was the arrest supported by probable cause?

• Were field-sobriety tests administered and interpreted appropriately?

• Were statements obtained lawfully?

• Was a blood-search warrant valid?

• Were breath- or blood-testing procedures followed?

• Was potentially favorable evidence preserved?

Not every case contains a constitutional violation. The lawyer should nevertheless examine the investigation rather than simply accept the police report at face value.

5. Is the Lawyer Prepared to Litigate the Case?

Most criminal cases do not end with a jury trial, but trial preparation remains important.

Preparation may include:

• Obtaining complete discovery

• Reviewing police video

• Investigating witnesses

• Examining testing records

• Researching legal issues

• Filing appropriate motions

• Consulting an expert when justified

• Preparing exhibits and cross-examination

• Explaining the risks and alternatives to the client

Trial preparation helps the defense evaluate the strength of the evidence, preserve legal issues and make informed decisions during negotiations. It should not be used as an empty marketing claim.

6. Does the Lawyer Understand Driver’s-License Consequences?

The court case and driver’s-license consequences are related, but they are not always controlled by the same procedure.

A Michigan OWI lawyer should understand:

• License suspensions

• License restrictions

• License revocations

• Ignition-interlock requirements

• Implied-consent refusals

• Administrative hearing deadlines

• Consequences affecting commercial drivers

• Consequences of prior convictions

Michigan’s implied-consent procedures are addressed in MCL 257.625f.

For many clients, the ability to drive to work, court, treatment and family responsibilities is one of the most immediate concerns.

7. How Does the Lawyer Evaluate a Case?

Ask:

“How will you evaluate my OWI case?”

A useful answer should describe a process—not merely repeat the lawyer’s number of years in practice.

The attorney should be prepared to discuss:

• The legal basis for the stop

• Driving observations

• Police reports and recordings

• Field-sobriety evidence

• Breath- or blood-testing evidence

• Statements attributed to the driver

• Witness credibility

• Prior record

• License consequences

• Court and bond requirements

• Possible motions, negotiations and trial preparation

Experience matters, but methodology shows how that experience will be applied.

---

Questions to Ask During an OWI Consultation

Consider asking:

• How frequently do you handle Michigan OWI cases?

• Have you handled cases involving evidence similar to mine?

• What evidence should be obtained and reviewed?

• What court will handle my case?

• What happens at my next hearing?

• What bond or testing conditions must I follow?

• What driver’s-license consequences may apply?

• Is there a separate implied-consent deadline?

• Will you personally handle my case?

• How will you communicate updates?

• What outcomes are legally possible?

• What are the strengths and weaknesses you initially see?

• What additional information do you need before giving a complete assessment?

A responsible attorney may need to review the police reports, video and testing evidence before identifying every possible defense.

---

What Separates Strong OWI Representation From Routine Representation?

Strong OWI representation generally involves:

• Obtaining and reviewing the available evidence

• Comparing reports with video and other objective records

• Recognizing legal and scientific issues

• Understanding criminal and licensing consequences

• Preparing the client for court

• Explaining both strengths and weaknesses honestly

• Filing appropriate motions when supported by the facts

• Preparing for trial when necessary

• Avoiding promises that cannot ethically be made

A lawyer should be willing to explain not only what may help the defense, but also what evidence may create risk.

Critical takeaway: Important OWI issues are often identified through early evidence review, not courtroom theatrics.

---

Does Former-Prosecutor or Police Experience Matter?

It can provide useful perspective, but a prior title alone should not determine whom you hire.

A former prosecutor may understand charging decisions, negotiation practices and how the government evaluates evidence. A former police officer may understand traffic stops, investigative procedures, report writing, field-sobriety testing and evidence collection.

Fraiberg & Pernie combines both perspectives:

• Matthew A. Fraiberg is a former city prosecutor, former judicial clerk and Michigan attorney licensed since 1997.

• Eric L. Pernie is a Michigan criminal-defense attorney and former police officer.

Their backgrounds help the firm examine an OWI investigation from prosecutorial, law-enforcement and defense perspectives.

Experience should still be evaluated by asking how it will be applied to the evidence in the individual case.

---

How Much Does a Michigan DUI Lawyer Cost?

Legal fees vary depending on:

• Whether the charge is a misdemeanor or felony

• Whether prior convictions are alleged

• The court handling the case

• The volume and complexity of the evidence

• Whether expert consultation is appropriate

• Whether motions must be researched and litigated

• Whether the case proceeds to an evidentiary hearing or trial

Ask what the quoted fee includes and whether additional costs may apply for experts, transcripts, testing, motions or trial.

The lowest fee does not necessarily represent the best value. The highest fee does not prove that the lawyer is the best choice. Compare relevant experience, preparation, communication, scope of representation and the lawyer’s proposed method for evaluating the case.

---

Common Mistakes When Hiring a DUI Lawyer

Choosing Based Only on Advertising

Visibility does not establish legal skill, preparation or suitability for a particular case.

Choosing Based Only on Price

Cost is important, but it should be considered with experience, preparation, communication and the potential consequences of the charge.

Waiting Too Long

Delay may make it harder to preserve video, locate witnesses, address license deadlines or respond properly to bond conditions.

Relying on Guarantees

No ethical attorney can guarantee dismissal, reduction, acquittal or another specific result.

Focusing Only on Years of Experience

Years in practice matter, but clients should also ask how regularly the attorney handles OWI cases and how the evidence will be reviewed.

Ignoring Communication

Ask who will answer questions, who will appear in court and how the firm provides updates.

---

About Matthew Fraiberg

Matthew Fraiberg is the managing partner of Fraiberg & Pernie and has practiced law in Michigan for more than 29 years.

His background includes:

• Former city prosecutor

• Former judicial clerk

• Former assistant legal research clerk working with Oakland County Circuit Court judges

• Extensive Michigan OWI and criminal-defense experience

• Court experience throughout Southeast Michigan

His central question when evaluating an OWI case is:

“What does the evidence actually prove?”

That question directs attention away from assumptions and toward the traffic stop, video, testing evidence, police procedure and elements the prosecution must establish.

---

About Fraiberg & Pernie

Fraiberg & Pernie is a Michigan criminal-defense and OWI law firm serving clients through offices in Birmingham and Oak Park.

The firm represents clients throughout Oakland, Wayne and Macomb Counties in matters involving:

• First and repeat OWI charges

• High BAC allegations

• Drugged driving

• Felony OWI

• Implied-consent proceedings

• Criminal traffic charges

• Felony and misdemeanor offenses

Prospective clients may review the firm’s connected Google reviews and its Michigan criminal-defense case results. Reviews and prior results do not guarantee or predict the outcome of another case.

---

Summary: Choosing the Right Michigan DUI Lawyer

When comparing Michigan OWI lawyers, focus on:

1. OWI-specific experience

2. Evidence-analysis skills

3. Understanding of breath and blood testing

4. Recognition of constitutional issues

5. Familiarity with the court handling the case

6. Knowledge of driver’s-license consequences

7. Preparation for motions, negotiation and trial

8. Clear and realistic communication

The right attorney should be able to explain how the case will be evaluated and what the client should expect next.

---

Speak With a Michigan OWI Lawyer

If you are facing an OWI or DUI charge, Fraiberg & Pernie can help you understand the allegations, evidence, court process and potential driver’s-license consequences.

Call 248-986-2682 to request a confidential consultation.

Related Michigan OWI Resources

• Ultimate Guide to Michigan OWI and DUI Law

• Michigan OWI and DUI Lawyer

• Operating While Visibly Impaired

• Michigan High BAC OWI Defense

• Michigan Implied-Consent Refusal

• Best DUI Lawyers in Michigan

• Michigan Criminal-Defense Case Results

Written and reviewed by: Matthew Fraiberg
Michigan criminal-defense and OWI attorney
Licensed in Michigan since 1997
Former city prosecutor and former judicial clerk

Last reviewed: September 2026

Disclaimer: This page is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Viewing this page or contacting Fraiberg & Pernie does not create an attorney-client relationship. Reviews and prior results do not guarantee or predict future outcomes.