Fraiberg & Pernie Case Results
Case Results
Michigan DUI, OWI & Criminal Defense Case Results | Fraiberg & Pernie
Real Cases. Real Evidence. Actual Defense Results.
Fraiberg & Pernie represents clients charged with Operating While Intoxicated (OWI), High BAC, repeat and felony OWI, domestic violence, drug offenses, theft, assault, criminal traffic offenses, and other crimes throughout Oakland, Wayne, and Macomb counties.
Our case results illustrate how examining police reports, body-camera and dash-camera recordings, breath and blood testing, medical evidence, witness statements, and constitutional issues can affect the outcome of a Michigan criminal case.
Matthew Fraiberg, a former City Prosecutor and former Judicial Clerk, has practiced Michigan law since 1997. Eric L. Pernie, a former police officer, brings additional law-enforcement experience to the firm’s criminal defense practice.
The representative results below identify the court, original charge, significant evidence or defense issue, outcome, and attorney responsible for the case.
Past results do not guarantee or predict the outcome of any future case. Every criminal matter depends on its individual facts, evidence, applicable law, and circumstances.
Facing an OWI or criminal charge? Call Fraiberg & Pernie at (248) 986-2682 for a confidential consultation.
Featured Michigan OWI & DUI Defense Results
OWI Dismissed After Traffic-Stop Evidence Challenged — 52-4 District Court, Troy
Original Charge: Operating While Intoxicated (OWI)
Court: 52-4 District Court, Troy, Oakland County
Key Evidence: Dash-camera footage and police observations
Defense Issue: Whether the officer had a lawful basis to stop the vehicle
Outcome: Evidence suppressed; OWI dismissed
Attorney: Matthew Fraiberg
Police alleged that the client was weaving while driving. The defense obtained and reviewed the dash-camera recording, which showed no lane departure or clear traffic violation.
The defense compared the recording with the officer’s stated justification for the stop and challenged its legality.
The court suppressed evidence obtained following the stop, and the OWI charge was dismissed.
Why this result matters: Police descriptions of driving behavior should be evaluated against available recordings. A successful challenge to the legality of a traffic stop can affect whether evidence may be used in court.
Learn about OWI defense in Troy’s 52-4 District Court.
OWI Reduced to Careless Driving After Breath-Test Concerns — 48th District Court
Original Charge: Operating While Intoxicated
Court: 48th District Court, Bloomfield Hills, Oakland County
Reported BAC: .09
Key Evidence: Client’s physical condition, vomiting, and breath-test evidence
Defense Issue: Reliability of the breath result under the circumstances
Outcome: OWI reduced to Careless Driving
Attorney: Matthew Fraiberg
The client had pulled off the roadway, activated the vehicle’s hazard lights, and was vomiting when police became involved.
The defense evaluated whether vomiting and the circumstances surrounding the breath test affected the reliability of the reported .09 BAC result.
The OWI charge was ultimately reduced to Careless Driving.
Why this result matters: The circumstances surrounding alcohol testing can be important. A reported BAC should be evaluated together with testing procedures, the client’s physical condition, and the remaining evidence.
OWI Reduced to Careless Driving After Hospital Blood Test — 48th District Court
Original Charge: Operating While Intoxicated
Court: 48th District Court, Bloomfield Hills, Oakland County
Reported Hospital Blood BAC: .06
Key Evidence: Accident investigation, field sobriety testing, medical circumstances, and hospital blood evidence
Defense Issue: Sobriety testing before medical attention and the strength of the impairment evidence
Outcome: OWI reduced to Careless Driving
Attorney: Matthew Fraiberg
The client was involved in a traffic accident. Police conducted field sobriety testing before the client received medical attention and reported observations that included allegedly slurred speech.
The defense evaluated those observations in light of the accident, the client’s medical circumstances, and a hospital blood result of .06.
The case was resolved with a reduction from OWI to Careless Driving.
Why this result matters: An accident does not automatically establish intoxication. Medical circumstances, testing conditions, and objective blood evidence may affect the evaluation of alleged impairment.
High BAC Reduced to OWVI — 48th District Court, Bloomfield Hills
Original Charge: High BAC OWI
Court: 48th District Court, Bloomfield Hills, Oakland County
Key Evidence: Chemical testing, police observations, and available video
Defense Issue: Whether the testing and investigation supported the enhanced alcohol allegation
Outcome: High BAC OWI reduced to Operating While Visibly Impaired (OWVI)
Attorney: Matthew Fraiberg
The defense examined the reported chemical-test evidence alongside the testing procedure, officer observations, available video, and the client’s recorded behavior.
Rather than evaluating the BAC result in isolation, the defense considered the entire investigation and the evidence supporting the enhanced High BAC charge.
The case was resolved with a reduction to OWVI.
Why this result matters: High BAC cases require careful attention to the chemical-test evidence and the legal requirements for the charged offense.
OWI Reduced to Careless Driving Following Diabetes-Related Evidence Review — 48th District Court
Original Charge: Operating While Intoxicated
Court: 48th District Court, Bloomfield Hills, Oakland County
Reported BAC: .08
Key Evidence: Medical condition, breath testing, and officer observations
Defense Issue: Whether diabetes affected the evaluation of alleged impairment or chemical-test evidence
Outcome: OWI reduced to Careless Driving
Attorney: Matthew Fraiberg
Fraiberg & Pernie represented an 82-year-old client with diabetes who faced an OWI charge following a reported .08 BAC result.
The defense reviewed the client’s medical condition, chemical-testing evidence, and officer observations, including whether the medical circumstances provided alternative explanations for alleged signs of impairment.
The OWI charge was reduced to Careless Driving.
Why this result matters: Medical evidence may be relevant to interpreting police observations and evaluating the reliability of certain testing evidence.
Commercial Driver Avoided OWI Conviction — 52-2 District Court, Clarkston
Original Charge: Operating While Intoxicated
Court: 52-2 District Court, Clarkston, Oakland County
Reported BAC: .10
Key Evidence: Breath-testing procedure
Defense Issue: Observation requirements before breath testing and commercial driver’s license consequences
Outcome: OWI reduced to Careless Driving; client retained CDL
Attorney: Matthew Fraiberg
A commercial driver faced an OWI charge that threatened the client’s livelihood.
The defense reviewed the arrest and chemical-testing process and identified an issue involving the observation procedure before breath testing.
The charge was reduced to Careless Driving, and the client retained the commercial driver’s license.
Why this result matters: Commercial drivers face particularly serious licensing consequences. Identifying procedural or evidentiary issues early can be critical.
OWI Reduced to Careless Driving After Snowstorm — 52-3 District Court
Original Charge: Operating While Intoxicated
Court: 52-3 District Court, Rochester Hills, Oakland County
Key Evidence: Snow, ice, driving conditions, and field sobriety testing
Defense Issue: Whether weather conditions explained the driving behavior and roadside-test performance
Outcome: OWI reduced to Careless Driving
Attorney: Eric L. Pernie
The client lost control of a vehicle during a snowstorm and acknowledged consuming alcohol earlier.
Field sobriety testing occurred on icy pavement.
The defense examined whether road conditions explained the loss of control and whether the testing environment affected the client’s ability to perform balance-based sobriety tests.
The OWI was reduced to Careless Driving.
Why this result matters: Environmental conditions can influence driving behavior and roadside testing. Those circumstances should be considered before attributing every observation to alcohol impairment.
High BAC Reduced to Impaired Driving After Medical-Evidence Review — 16th District Court
Original Charge: High BAC OWI
Court: 16th District Court, Livonia, Wayne County
Reported BAC: .17
Key Evidence: GERD, acid reflux, and breath-testing procedure
Defense Issue: Whether medical circumstances affected the evaluation of the breath-test evidence
Outcome: High BAC reduced to Impaired Driving
Attorney: Matthew Fraiberg
The client had documented GERD and acid reflux.
The defense reviewed the medical circumstances and breath-testing procedure to evaluate the reported chemical-test result.
The High BAC charge was reduced to Impaired Driving.
Why this result matters: Medical history and the circumstances of chemical testing may be important in evaluating an OWI prosecution.
Additional 48th District Court OWI Results — Bloomfield Hills
Fraiberg & Pernie handles OWI cases arising in Bloomfield Hills, Bloomfield Township, West Bloomfield, Birmingham, and other communities within the 48th District Court’s jurisdiction.
Second-Offense OWI Reduced to First Offense
Original Charge: OWI Second Offense
Court: 48th District Court, Bloomfield Hills
Key Facts: Prior OWI approximately 22 years earlier; reported BAC .10
Defense Focus: Current OWI evidence and repeat-offense allegation
Outcome: Reduced to OWI First Offense
Attorney: Matthew Fraiberg
The client faced a repeat-offense OWI allegation based on an earlier conviction approximately 22 years before the current case.
The defense evaluated the present charge and the repeat-offense enhancement.
The case was resolved as OWI First Offense rather than OWI Second Offense.
First-Offense OWI Reduced to OWVI
Original Charge: Operating While Intoxicated
Court: 48th District Court, Bloomfield Hills
Key Facts: No prior OWI, no accident, and significant professional licensing concerns
Defense Focus: OWI evidence and consequences of the charged offense
Outcome: OWI reduced to OWVI
Attorney: Matthew Fraiberg
A young professional with no prior OWI conviction faced a charge that could affect driving privileges and employment.
The defense reviewed the evidence and sought a resolution appropriate to the circumstances.
The charge was reduced to Operating While Visibly Impaired.
OWI Reduced to OWVI After Field Sobriety Evidence Challenged
Original Charge: Operating While Intoxicated
Court: 48th District Court, Bloomfield Hills
Key Evidence: Police report, field sobriety testing, and absence of corroborating video
Defense Issue: Whether the officer’s conclusions were supported by objective evidence
Outcome: OWI reduced to OWVI
Attorney: Eric L. Pernie
Police alleged that the client failed roadside sobriety testing.
The defense examined the officer’s written account and the absence of video corroborating the reported performance.
The OWI charge was reduced to Operating While Visibly Impaired.
Learn more about OWI defense in the 48th District Court.
Additional Oakland County OWI & Criminal Defense Results
52-4 District Court — Troy and Clawson
High BAC Reduced to OWI
Original Charge: High BAC OWI
Court: 52-4 District Court, Troy
Reported BAC: .19
Defense Focus: OWI evidence and consequences for employment and driving privileges
Outcome: High BAC reduced to OWI
Attorney: Matthew Fraiberg
The client faced an enhanced High BAC allegation involving a reported .19 alcohol concentration.
The defense evaluated the evidence and the consequences of the charge.
The case was resolved as OWI rather than High BAC.
Second-Offense OWI Reduced to OWI Without Repeat Enhancement
Original Charge: OWI Second Offense
Court: 52-4 District Court, Troy
Reported BAC: .09
Key Facts: Prior OWI approximately 16 years earlier
Outcome: Reduced to OWI without the second-offense enhancement
Attorney: Matthew Fraiberg
The defense evaluated the current OWI evidence and repeat-offense allegation.
The charge was reduced to OWI without the second-offense enhancement.
OWI Reduced to OWVI
Original Charge: Operating While Intoxicated
Court: 52-4 District Court, Troy
Reported BAC: .10
Key Facts: Older client with no prior OWI conviction
Outcome: OWI reduced to OWVI
Attorney: Matthew Fraiberg
The defense evaluated the circumstances of the allegation, the client’s history, and the evidence.
The charge was reduced to Operating While Visibly Impaired.
Retail Fraud Resolved Without Jail — Clawson
Original Charge: Retail Fraud
Court: 52-4 District Court
Defense Issue: Intent, store evidence, property value, and mitigation
Outcome: Resolved without jail
Attorney: Eric L. Pernie
The defense reviewed loss-prevention information, store evidence, police reports, property value, and the client’s circumstances.
The case was resolved without incarceration.
52-3 District Court — Rochester Hills
First-Offense OWI Reduced to OWVI
Original Charge: OWI First Offense
Court: 52-3 District Court
Defense Issue: Traffic stop, field sobriety testing, video, and breath-testing evidence
Outcome: OWI reduced to OWVI
Attorney: Matthew Fraiberg
The defense evaluated police observations, available recordings, field sobriety testing, preliminary breath testing, and chemical-test evidence.
The OWI charge was reduced to Operating While Visibly Impaired.
Learn about 52-3 District Court OWI defense.
52-1 District Court — Novi
OWI Reduced to Non-Alcohol Offense
Original Charge: Operating While Intoxicated
Court: 52-1 District Court, Novi
Defense Issue: Whether the prosecution could establish when the vehicle was operated
Outcome: OWI reduced to a non-alcohol Disorderly Person offense
Attorney: Eric L. Pernie
The client was found in a parked vehicle and acknowledged driving earlier.
The defense focused on whether the prosecution could establish a connection between the time of vehicle operation and the alleged intoxication.
The charge was reduced to a non-alcohol offense.
Second-Offense OWI Reduced to First Offense
Original Charge: OWI Second Offense
Court: 52-1 District Court, Novi
Defense Issue: Video, field sobriety evidence, and prior-offense enhancement
Outcome: OWI Second Offense reduced to OWI First Offense
Attorney: Matthew Fraiberg
The defense examined the current OWI evidence and whether the alleged prior conviction supported the enhanced charge.
The case was resolved as OWI First Offense.
Learn about OWI defense in the 52-1 District Court.
44th District Court — Royal Oak
Domestic Violence Dismissed
Original Charge: Domestic Violence
Court: 44th District Court, Royal Oak
Defense Issue: Witness credibility, inconsistent statements, self-defense, and physical evidence
Outcome: Domestic Violence dismissed
Attorney: Eric L. Pernie
The defense compared witness statements with the physical evidence and examined the circumstances surrounding the confrontation.
The charge was dismissed.
43rd District Court — Ferndale
OWI Reduced to OWVI
Original Charge: Operating While Intoxicated
Court: 43rd District Court, Ferndale
Defense Issue: Body-camera and dash-camera evidence compared with officer observations
Outcome: OWI reduced to OWVI
Attorney: Matthew Fraiberg
The defense compared the officer’s written description with video evidence showing the client’s appearance, speech, balance, and behavior.
The case was resolved with a reduction to OWVI.
46th District Court — Southfield
Controlled Substance Possession Dismissed
Original Charge: Controlled Substance Possession
Court: 46th District Court, Southfield
Defense Issue: Constructive possession, knowledge, and connection to alleged contraband
Outcome: Charge dismissed
Attorney: Matthew Fraiberg
The alleged controlled substance was found inside a vehicle occupied by multiple people.
The defense challenged whether the prosecution could establish knowing possession by the client.
The charge was dismissed.
47th District Court — Farmington Hills
Retail Fraud Dismissed
Original Charge: Retail Fraud
Court: 47th District Court, Farmington Hills
Defense Issue: Intentional theft versus inadvertent checkout error
Outcome: Retail Fraud dismissed after negotiated resolution
Attorney: Eric L. Pernie
The defense reviewed surveillance and transaction evidence and challenged whether the circumstances established criminal intent.
The charge was dismissed following a negotiated resolution.
51st District Court — Waterford
Drug Possession Dismissed
Original Charge: Controlled Substance Possession
Court: 51st District Court, Waterford
Defense Issue: Search and seizure, knowing possession, and evidentiary documentation
Outcome: Drug Possession dismissed
Attorney: Matthew Fraiberg
The defense examined the legal basis for the search and whether the prosecution could establish knowing possession.
The charge was dismissed.
Assault and Battery Dismissed
Original Charge: Assault and Battery
Court: 51st District Court, Waterford
Defense Issue: Self-defense, conflicting witness accounts, injuries, and physical evidence
Outcome: Assault and Battery dismissed
Attorney: Eric L. Pernie
The defense evaluated conflicting accounts of the incident, who initiated the confrontation, and the available physical evidence.
The charge was dismissed.
52-2 District Court — Clarkston
Probation Violation Dismissed
Original Allegation: Probation Violation
Court: 52-2 District Court, Clarkston
Defense Issue: Probation conditions, compliance records, and evidence of the alleged violation
Outcome: Probation Violation dismissed
Attorney: Eric L. Pernie
The defense examined probation records and the evidence offered to establish the alleged violation.
The violation was dismissed.
Wayne County DUI, OWI & Criminal Defense Results
Fraiberg & Pernie represents clients in Wayne County district courts, including Livonia, Redford, Westland, Dearborn Heights, Taylor, Romulus, Plymouth, Canton, and Detroit.
16th District Court — Livonia
Reckless Driving Reduced to Civil Infraction
Original Charge: Reckless Driving
Court: 16th District Court, Livonia
Defense Issue: Whether the driving met the legal requirements for criminal Reckless Driving
Outcome: Reduced to a civil traffic infraction
Attorney: Eric L. Pernie
The defense evaluated whether the conduct established the elements of Reckless Driving rather than a lesser traffic offense.
The criminal charge was reduced to a civil infraction.
17th District Court — Redford
High BAC Reduced to Impaired Driving
Original Charge: High BAC OWI
Court: 17th District Court, Redford
Defense Issue: Recent knee replacement, balance limitations, and field sobriety testing
Outcome: High BAC reduced to Impaired Driving
Attorney: Matthew Fraiberg
The client had recently undergone knee-replacement surgery.
The defense evaluated whether the client’s medical condition affected performance on balance-based sobriety tests.
The charge was reduced to Impaired Driving.
Larceny Dismissed
Original Charge: Larceny
Court: 17th District Court, Redford
Defense Issue: Ownership, consent, possession, and criminal intent
Outcome: Larceny dismissed
Attorney: Matthew Fraiberg
Communications and evidence concerning ownership and possession raised questions about whether the allegations reflected criminal conduct or a property dispute.
The charge was dismissed.
Domestic Violence Dismissed
Original Charge: Domestic Violence
Court: 17th District Court, Redford
Defense Issue: Witness credibility, consistency, and corroborating evidence
Outcome: Domestic Violence dismissed
Attorney: Eric L. Pernie
The defense examined witness accounts, the police investigation, and the evidence supporting the allegation.
The charge was dismissed.
18th District Court — Westland
OWI Reduced to OWVI
Original Charge: Operating While Intoxicated
Court: 18th District Court, Westland
Defense Issue: Driving observations, video, field sobriety testing, chemical testing, and investigation timeline
Outcome: OWI reduced to OWVI
Attorney: Eric L. Pernie
The defense examined the entire investigation, including the relationship between police observations and chemical-test evidence.
The charge was reduced to Operating While Visibly Impaired.
Probation Violation Dismissed
Original Allegation: Probation Violation
Court: 18th District Court, Westland
Defense Issue: Alleged violation and supporting documentation
Outcome: Probation Violation dismissed
Attorney: Matthew Fraiberg
The defense evaluated the alleged noncompliance and the evidence supporting it.
The probation violation was dismissed.
20th District Court — Dearborn Heights
Driving While License Suspended Dismissed
Original Charge: Driving While License Suspended (DWLS)
Court: 20th District Court, Dearborn Heights
Defense Issue: Driving record, notice, and underlying license status
Outcome: DWLS dismissed
Attorney: Eric L. Pernie
The defense reviewed the underlying licensing problem and the circumstances of the charge.
After the licensing issue was addressed, the criminal charge was dismissed.
23rd District Court — Taylor
Resisting and Obstructing Reduced to Lesser Offense
Original Charge: Resisting and Obstructing a Police Officer
Court: 23rd District Court, Taylor
Defense Issue: Body-camera footage, police commands, and ability to comply
Outcome: Reduced to Disorderly Person
Attorney: Matthew Fraiberg
The defense compared body-camera recordings with the police reports, including the commands given and the client’s ability to comply.
The charge was reduced to a lesser offense.
34th District Court — Romulus
High BAC OWI Reduced
Original Charge: High BAC OWI
Court: 34th District Court, Romulus
Defense Issue: Chemical testing, traffic stop, field sobriety evidence, and police observations
Outcome: High BAC OWI reduced
Attorney: Eric L. Pernie
The defense evaluated the chemical-test evidence in the context of the entire investigation.
The enhanced High BAC charge was reduced.
35th District Court — Plymouth and Canton
Drugged-Driving Charge Reduced to OWVI
Original Charge: OWI / Operating Under the Influence of a Controlled Substance
Court: 35th District Court
Defense Issue: Toxicology, timing, observed impairment, and driving evidence
Outcome: Reduced to OWVI
Attorney: Eric L. Pernie
The defense evaluated the toxicology evidence together with the timing of the alleged driving and the client’s observed behavior.
The charge was reduced to OWVI.
OWI Reduced to Civil Infraction
Original Charge: Operating While Intoxicated
Court: 35th District Court, Plymouth
Defense Issue: Traffic stop, field sobriety testing, chemical evidence, and video
Outcome: OWI reduced to a civil infraction
Attorney: Matthew Fraiberg
The defense reviewed the complete investigation and the evidence supporting the alcohol-related charge.
The OWI was reduced to a civil infraction.
36th District Court — Detroit
OWI Reduced to Reckless Driving After Blood-Evidence Review
Original Charge: Operating While Intoxicated
Court: 36th District Court, Detroit
Reported Blood BAC: .12
Defense Issue: Laboratory documentation and chain of custody
Outcome: OWI reduced to Reckless Driving
Attorney: Matthew Fraiberg
The defense reviewed laboratory records and identified a chain-of-custody issue involving the blood evidence.
The OWI charge was reduced to Reckless Driving.
First-Offense OWI Reduced to OWVI
Original Charge: OWI First Offense
Court: 36th District Court, Detroit
Defense Issue: Police video, field sobriety testing, breath-testing procedure, and observations
Outcome: OWI reduced to OWVI
Attorney: Eric L. Pernie
The defense examined the traffic stop, police report, available video, roadside testing, and chemical-testing procedure.
The charge was reduced to Operating While Visibly Impaired.
Retail Fraud Dismissed
Original Charge: Retail Fraud
Court: 36th District Court, Detroit
Defense Issue: Criminal intent, witness information, and store evidence
Outcome: Retail Fraud dismissed
Attorney: Eric L. Pernie
The defense evaluated the available evidence and whether it established the elements of the charged offense.
The charge was dismissed.
Learn more about Wayne County OWI defense.
Macomb County DUI & Criminal Defense Results
Fraiberg & Pernie also handles OWI and criminal defense matters in Macomb County, including Shelby Township, Sterling Heights, Clinton Township, Warren, and Eastpointe.
41-A District Court — Shelby Township
Domestic Violence Dismissed
Original Charge: Domestic Violence
Court: 41-A District Court, Shelby Township
Defense Issue: Witness statements, police reports, body-camera footage, 911 information, and credibility
Outcome: Domestic Violence dismissed
Attorney: Matthew Fraiberg
The defense examined the available evidence and identified inconsistencies relevant to the allegation.
The charge was dismissed.
41-A District Court — Sterling Heights
Drug Possession Reduced
Original Charge: Controlled Substance Possession
Court: 41-A District Court, Sterling Heights
Defense Issue: Search legality, knowing possession, and evidentiary documentation
Outcome: Reduced to a lesser offense
Attorney: Eric L. Pernie
The defense examined the search, seizure, and evidence connecting the alleged controlled substance to the client.
The charge was reduced.
41-B District Court — Clinton Township
Felony Third-Offense OWI Reduced
Original Charge: Felony Third-Offense OWI
Court: 41-B District Court / Macomb County proceedings
Defense Issue: Chemical testing, field sobriety testing, officer observations, and prior-offense history
Outcome: Felony Third-Offense OWI reduced to regular OWI
Attorney: Eric L. Pernie
The defense examined the current OWI evidence and the prosecution’s ability to establish the repeat-offense requirements.
The case was resolved with a reduction from the felony third-offense allegation.
37th District Court — Warren
Retail Fraud Dismissed
Original Charge: Retail Fraud
Court: 37th District Court, Warren
Defense Issue: Loss-prevention evidence, surveillance, valuation, and intent
Outcome: Retail Fraud dismissed
Attorney: Matthew Fraiberg
The defense examined whether the evidence established intentional theft.
The charge was dismissed.
Felony Embezzlement Reduced to Misdemeanor
Original Charge: Felony Embezzlement
Court: 37th District Court, Warren
Defense Issue: Accounting records, authorization, ownership of funds, and criminal intent
Outcome: Reduced to misdemeanor at district court
Attorney: Matthew Fraiberg
The defense reviewed financial records, communications, and evidence concerning authorization for the disputed transactions.
The felony allegation was reduced to a misdemeanor.
38th District Court — Eastpointe
Probation Continued Without Jail
Original Allegation: Probation Violation
Court: 38th District Court, Eastpointe
Defense Issue: Testing records, reporting compliance, employment, and mitigation
Outcome: Probation continued without jail
Attorney: Eric L. Pernie
The defense reviewed the client’s compliance history and relevant mitigating circumstances.
Probation was continued, with no jail imposed.
What These Case Results Demonstrate About Criminal Defense
No two criminal cases are identical. The results above illustrate several recurring issues that may be important in defending an OWI or criminal charge.
Traffic Stops and Police Video: Dash-camera and body-camera recordings may provide evidence that supports, qualifies, or contradicts an officer’s written observations.
Breath and Blood Testing: Chemical-test results should be evaluated alongside testing procedures, relevant medical circumstances, equipment and laboratory records, and other evidence.
Field Sobriety Testing: Physical limitations, medical conditions, weather, road surfaces, and testing procedures can affect how roadside performance should be interpreted.
Criminal Intent and Witness Credibility: In theft, assault, domestic violence, and possession cases, the prosecution must establish the applicable elements of the offense. Witness statements and physical evidence may raise important factual questions.
Repeat-Offense Enhancements: Prior convictions and the legal requirements for enhanced charges can materially affect the allegations and potential consequences.
Driver’s License and Employment Consequences: An OWI charge can create concerns extending beyond the courtroom, particularly for commercial drivers and licensed professionals.
The central principle is straightforward: the evidence and applicable law—not merely the original accusation—must guide the defense strategy.
Frequently Asked Questions About Michigan OWI & Criminal Case Results
Can an OWI charge be dismissed in Michigan?
Yes, depending on the facts and applicable law. For example, a Troy OWI case described above resulted in dismissal after the defense successfully challenged evidence obtained following a traffic stop. Dismissal is not guaranteed in any case.
Can a Michigan OWI be reduced to Careless Driving or OWVI?
Yes, reductions may be possible depending on the evidence, legal issues, negotiations, and circumstances. The representative cases on this page include OWI charges reduced to Careless Driving, Reckless Driving, OWVI, and other offenses.
Can a High BAC charge be reduced?
Potentially. Fraiberg & Pernie’s representative results include High BAC charges reduced to OWI or OWVI. The outcome depends on the specific case, including the chemical-test evidence and other relevant circumstances.
Why does experience in a particular Michigan district court matter?
Court-specific experience may help an attorney understand local procedures, scheduling, testing and supervision requirements, and the practical issues that arise in that court. Every case still requires an individualized legal and evidentiary evaluation.
Do past case results mean I will receive the same outcome?
No. Past results do not guarantee or predict future outcomes. Each case depends on its facts, evidence, legal issues, criminal history, and applicable law.
About the Attorneys Behind These Results
Matthew Fraiberg — Managing Partner
Matthew Fraiberg has practiced Michigan law since 1997.
His background includes service as a former City Prosecutor, former Judicial Clerk, and former Assistant Legal Research Clerk working with Oakland County Circuit Court judges.
Fraiberg also serves as Managed Assigned Counsel for the indigent-defense program serving the 48th District Court. This administrative responsibility is distinct from his private criminal defense representation.
His practice includes Michigan OWI/DUI, High BAC, repeat and felony OWI, criminal traffic, domestic violence, drug offenses, and other criminal defense matters.
Eric L. Pernie — Partner
Eric L. Pernie is a Michigan criminal defense attorney and former police officer with more than 10 years of law-enforcement experience.
His background provides perspective when evaluating traffic stops, field sobriety testing, police investigations, evidence collection, police reports, and video recordings.
Together, Fraiberg and Pernie bring experience from criminal defense, prosecution, court operations, and law enforcement to their representation of Michigan criminal defendants.
Related Michigan OWI & Criminal Defense Resources
Speak With a Michigan OWI or Criminal Defense Attorney
If you have been arrested or charged with OWI, High BAC, domestic violence, drug possession, assault, theft, or another criminal offense, obtaining and evaluating the evidence early may be important.
Fraiberg & Pernie represents clients in Oakland County, Wayne County, Macomb County, and throughout Southeast Michigan.
Call (248) 986-2682 to request a confidential consultation.
Fraiberg & Pernie
1000 S. Old Woodward Avenue, Suite 103
Birmingham, Michigan 48009
Phone: (248) 986-2682
Website: fpattorneys.com
Important Case Results Disclaimer: These examples describe representative matters handled by Fraiberg & Pernie. Past results do not guarantee, promise, or predict similar results in another case. Each criminal matter depends on its unique facts, evidence, applicable law, and circumstances. This page is informational and does not create an attorney-client relationship.
Written by: Matthew Fraiberg, Managing Partner, Michigan criminal defense and OWI attorney, former City Prosecutor and former Judicial Clerk.
Legally reviewed by: Eric L. Pernie, Partner, Michigan criminal defense and OWI attorney and former police officer.
Last Reviewed and Updated: November 2026
Practice Areas
Schedule a Consultation!
Fill out the information below and we will get back to you as soon as possible.
Testimonials
Success Stories
Frequently Asked Questions — Wayne County Criminal Defense Lawyers
Q: When should I hire a Wayne County criminal defense lawyer?
A: You should hire a defense lawyer as soon as you learn you are under investigation or charged. Early action helps protect your rights and may reduce or prevent charges.
Q: Do I need a lawyer for a first-time DUI or OWI in Wayne County?
A: Yes. Even a first DUI or OWI can lead to license suspension, fines, and a criminal record. A defense lawyer can challenge the stop, the testing, and the evidence.
Q: What cases do Wayne County criminal defense lawyers handle?
A: They handle DUI and OWI charges, drug offenses, assault, theft, domestic violence, felony charges, and misdemeanor cases.
Q: Can a criminal charge be reduced or dismissed in Wayne County?
A: In many cases, yes. For example, lawyers can challenge evidence, negotiate with prosecutors, and file legal motions that lead to reductions or dismissals.
Q: What should I do after an arrest in Wayne County?
A: First, remain silent. Next, do not answer police questions. Then, ask for a criminal defense lawyer immediately.
Wayne County criminal defense lawyers help clients facing DUI, OWI, felony, and misdemeanor charges throughout Detroit and surrounding communities. If you are searching for a criminal defense attorney in Wayne County Michigan, fast legal help can make a major difference in the result.
