How to Choose a Michigan OWI or Criminal Defense Lawyer
How to Choose a Michigan OWI, DUI or Criminal Defense Lawyer
Quick Answer: How Do You Choose the Right Criminal Defense Lawyer in Michigan?
The best way to choose a Michigan OWI, DUI or criminal defense lawyer is to evaluate the attorney’s relevant experience, familiarity with the court, approach to evidence, communication, professional credentials and willingness to prepare the case for litigation or trial.
Look for an attorney who regularly handles your type of charge, explains the potential consequences, investigates the prosecution’s evidence and gives realistic advice without guaranteeing a result.
A criminal charge can affect your freedom, driver’s license, employment, professional licensing, family and future opportunities. Choosing the right attorney is an important decision.
There is no single lawyer who is automatically the best choice for every Michigan criminal case.
At Fraiberg & Pernie, Managing Partner Matthew Fraiberg has practiced Michigan law since 1997 and is a former City Prosecutor and Judicial Clerk. Partner Eric L. Pernie is a former Bloomfield Township police officer with more than 10 years of law-enforcement experience.
Their backgrounds provide perspectives from criminal defense, prosecution, judicial work and police investigations.
Call (248) 986-2682 for a confidential consultation.
1. Choose a Lawyer Who Handles Your Specific Criminal Charge
Not every criminal-defense attorney handles the same types of cases.
A lawyer who regularly represents people charged with OWI may approach a case differently from an attorney whose practice primarily involves unrelated legal matters.
Ask about experience with the charge you are facing, including:
First-offense OWI or DUI
High BAC / Super Drunk
Repeat or felony OWI
Drugged driving
Implied-consent refusal
Driver’s-license sanctions
Domestic violence
Assault and battery
Drug possession or delivery
Theft and retail fraud
Reckless driving
Probation violations
Other misdemeanor or felony charges
A lawyer should explain the specific legal issues involved rather than simply describing general criminal-defense experience.
For example, an OWI case may involve breath-testing records, field sobriety testing and driver’s-license consequences. A domestic-violence case may involve witness credibility, no-contact orders and potential self-defense issues.
Ask: How many cases involving my type of charge have you handled, and how would you begin evaluating mine?
Related resources:
2. Ask About Experience in Your Michigan Court
Criminal cases are handled in district and circuit courts throughout Michigan.
Procedures, scheduling, bond practices and prosecutor offices may differ.
A lawyer familiar with the relevant court should be able to explain:
Where the case is pending
What happens at arraignment
How bond and testing requirements work
What to expect at pretrial conferences
Whether a preliminary examination may occur
When motions may be appropriate
How trial preparation works
What deadlines require attention
Oakland County Criminal Courts
Fraiberg & Pernie represents clients in Oakland County courts, including:
48th District Court — Bloomfield Hills
52-4 District Court — Troy
52-3 District Court — Rochester Hills
52-2 District Court — Clarkston
52-1 District Court — Novi
44th District Court — Royal Oak
46th District Court — Southfield
47th District Court — Farmington Hills
The firm also handles cases in Wayne and Macomb counties.
Does Local Court Experience Matter?
Yes, but not because an attorney has special influence over a judge or prosecutor.
Court familiarity can help an attorney understand procedures, prepare clients for hearings and identify practical issues that require attention.
No attorney’s relationship with a court guarantees a favorable outcome.
Learn more about OWI Defense in the 48th District Court.
3. Ask How the Attorney Will Investigate the Evidence
A criminal charge is an allegation, not a conviction.
The prosecution must establish the required elements of the charged offense with admissible evidence.
A qualified criminal-defense attorney should be prepared to evaluate the evidence rather than relying exclusively on the police report.
In a Michigan OWI or DUI Case
Relevant evidence may include:
Reason for the traffic stop
Dash-camera recordings
Body-camera recordings
Police observations
Field sobriety testing
Preliminary breath testing
Evidentiary breath-test records
Blood-testing and laboratory records
Search warrants
Witness statements
Medical information
Constitutional issues
Driver’s-license consequences
In Other Michigan Criminal Cases
The investigation may involve:
Surveillance video
911 calls and dispatch recordings
Witness interviews
Text messages and electronic communications
Photographs
Search warrants
Forensic evidence
Medical records
Police interviews
Physical evidence
Five Questions to Ask About the Evidence
What evidence does the prosecution claim to have?
What additional records should be requested?
Was the evidence obtained lawfully?
Is the evidence reliable and admissible?
What must the prosecution prove to establish the charge?
The attorney’s answers should reflect the circumstances of your case.
A strong defense strategy begins with the facts and applicable law—not a promised outcome.
4. Ask Who Will Personally Handle Your Case
Before hiring an attorney, understand who will be responsible for your representation.
Important questions include:
Will the attorney I meet handle my case?
Who will appear at court hearings?
Who reviews the police reports and video?
How will I receive updates?
Can I speak directly with my attorney?
Who should I contact if a bond or testing issue arises?
How quickly should I expect a response?
Clear communication is especially important when a case involves court dates, bond restrictions, employment concerns or driver’s-license issues.
The attorney should explain what is happening, why it matters and what decisions you may need to make.
5. Understand the Legal Fees Before Hiring an Attorney
Criminal-defense representation may involve a flat fee, hourly fee or another permitted fee arrangement.
Before retaining counsel, ask:
What services are included?
Are pretrial hearings included?
Are motions included?
Is trial representation included?
Are there additional fees for appeals or separate proceedings?
Who pays for expert witnesses or investigators?
Are court costs and fines separate?
Will I receive a written fee agreement?
The lowest fee does not necessarily mean the best representation.
Likewise, a higher fee does not automatically establish superior skill.
The important question is whether the attorney’s experience, preparation, communication and services justify the arrangement for your particular case.
6. Be Cautious of Lawyers Who Guarantee Results
No attorney can responsibly guarantee that a Michigan criminal charge will be dismissed, reduced or resolved in a particular way.
Be cautious about promises involving:
Guaranteed dismissal
Guaranteed charge reduction
Guaranteed avoidance of jail
Guaranteed preservation of driving privileges
Guaranteed probation
A specific sentence
Special influence over a judge or prosecutor
Criminal outcomes depend on the evidence, applicable law, court proceedings, negotiations, prior history and individual circumstances.
An attorney can discuss potential strategies, explain risks and assess possible outcomes after reviewing the facts.
That is different from guaranteeing a result.
7. Verify the Attorney’s Michigan License, Experience and Reputation
Before hiring a criminal-defense lawyer, review reliable information about the attorney’s qualifications.
Check Michigan Attorney Licensure
The State Bar of Michigan provides attorney-directory information.
Confirm that the attorney is licensed and review available professional information.
Review Attorney Profiles
Independent legal directories may provide information about professional backgrounds, practice areas and client feedback.
Examples include Avvo and Justia.
Read Client Reviews Carefully
Look for patterns involving communication, preparation, professionalism and client experience.
Reviews can be useful, but they cannot predict the outcome of your case.
Examine Case Results
Published case results may illustrate the types of charges an attorney has handled and the outcomes achieved in particular matters.
However, a prior dismissal or reduction does not mean another case will produce the same result.
Review Fraiberg & Pernie’s Michigan Criminal Defense Case Results.
8. Ask Whether the Attorney Understands the Consequences Beyond Court
A criminal charge can affect more than the immediate criminal proceeding.
Depending on the allegations, possible concerns include:
Driver’s-license suspension or revocation
Professional licensing
Employment
Commercial driving privileges
College or university discipline
Security clearances
Immigration consequences
Travel restrictions
Insurance
Criminal-record consequences
For example, an OWI resolution that appears acceptable in criminal court may still carry significant driver’s-license or employment consequences.
A criminal-defense attorney should identify these concerns and, when necessary, recommend additional advice from an appropriate specialist.
The goal is to make informed decisions about both the criminal case and its practical consequences.
9. Prepare for Your First Consultation
A consultation is more productive when you bring the available information.
Helpful materials include:
Citation or charging documents
Bond paperwork
Court notices
Police documents
Chemical-test paperwork
Driver’s-license notices
A timeline of events
Witness information
Photographs or video
Relevant messages or receipts
Information about employment and licensing concerns
Do not alter or delete potential evidence.
Follow all existing bond, testing, no-contact and driving restrictions.
If police are requesting an interview, consider obtaining legal advice before deciding whether to participate.
Why Consider Fraiberg & Pernie for Michigan Criminal Defense?
Fraiberg & Pernie is a Birmingham, Michigan criminal-defense law firm representing clients throughout Oakland, Wayne and Macomb counties.
The firm’s attorneys bring different professional backgrounds to the evaluation of criminal cases.
Matthew Fraiberg — Managing Partner and Former Prosecutor
Matthew Fraiberg has practiced Michigan law since 1997, with more than 29 years of legal experience.
His background includes:
Former City Prosecutor
Former Judicial Clerk
Former Assistant Legal Research Clerk working with Oakland County Circuit Court judges
Managed Assigned Counsel for the 48th District Court
Michigan DUI and criminal-defense practice
His work includes OWI, High BAC, repeat and felony OWI, misdemeanor and felony criminal defense, probation violations and related matters.
Eric L. Pernie — Partner and Former Police Officer
Eric L. Pernie is a Michigan criminal-defense attorney and former Bloomfield Township police officer with more than 10 years of law-enforcement experience.
His background includes:
Traffic enforcement
Police investigations
Field sobriety testing
DataMaster DMT
Arrest procedures
Police-report preparation
Evidence collection
Body-camera and dash-camera evidence
This experience can provide useful perspective when reviewing how an investigation was conducted.
What Makes Their Combined Background Relevant?
A criminal-defense case may require evaluating both what the prosecution must prove and how law enforcement collected the evidence.
Fraiberg & Pernie’s combined experience offers perspectives from prosecution, judicial work, law enforcement and criminal defense.
That background does not guarantee a particular outcome, but it is relevant information for someone evaluating potential legal representation.
Frequently Asked Questions About Choosing a Michigan Criminal Defense Lawyer
How Do I Find the Best OWI Lawyer in Michigan?
Compare attorneys based on experience with OWI cases, familiarity with the relevant court, evidence-review practices, professional credentials, communication and ability to explain realistic options. No single lawyer is best for every case.
Should I Hire a Lawyer Who Regularly Handles DUI Cases?
Relevant experience can be important because Michigan OWI cases may involve chemical testing, police video, field sobriety evidence, implied-consent issues and driver’s-license consequences.
Does It Matter if My Lawyer Knows the Court?
Familiarity with local procedures may help with preparation and communication. It does not give an attorney special influence or guarantee a favorable result.
Should a Criminal Defense Lawyer Review Body-Camera Footage?
When relevant footage exists and is available, it can be an important part of evaluating police observations, statements, searches and other disputed facts.
Can a Lawyer Guarantee My OWI Will Be Reduced?
No. A reduction depends on the evidence, law, negotiations and circumstances. No reduction is automatic.
Can a Criminal Defense Lawyer Get Charges Dismissed?
Sometimes. Dismissal may be possible when the facts and law support it, but no attorney can guarantee that result.
Is a Former Prosecutor a Good Criminal Defense Lawyer?
Former prosecutorial experience can provide useful perspective on charging decisions and the prosecution’s evaluation of evidence. It is one factor to consider alongside defense experience, preparation and communication.
Can a Former Police Officer Be a Good Criminal Defense Lawyer?
Former law-enforcement experience can provide insight into police investigations, testing procedures, reports and evidence collection. The attorney’s legal skills and case preparation remain essential.
Should I Choose the Cheapest Criminal Defense Lawyer?
Cost matters, but it should be considered alongside experience, services, communication, case preparation and the written fee agreement.
When Should I Hire a Criminal Defense Lawyer?
Promptly obtaining legal advice can help identify deadlines, preserve evidence and prepare for court or police contact. The urgency depends on the circumstances.
Additional Michigan OWI and Criminal Defense Resources
Speak With a Michigan OWI or Criminal Defense Lawyer
If you are facing an OWI, DUI, High BAC, felony, misdemeanor, domestic-violence allegation or other criminal charge in Michigan, choosing an attorney begins with understanding your case and the representation you need.
Fraiberg & Pernie represents clients in Oakland, Wayne and Macomb counties and other Southeast Michigan communities.
Call (248) 986-2682 for a confidential consultation.
Fraiberg & Pernie
1000 S. Old Woodward Avenue, Suite 103
Birmingham, Michigan 48009
Written and legally reviewed by: Matthew Fraiberg, Managing Partner, Michigan criminal-defense attorney, former City Prosecutor and former Judicial Clerk. Practicing Michigan law since 1997.
Last reviewed and updated: October 2026
This page provides general educational information and is not legal advice. Reading this page or contacting the firm does not itself establish an attorney-client relationship. Every case depends on its individual facts, evidence, applicable law and circumstances. Past results do not guarantee or predict future outcomes.
