Rochester 52-3 Criminal Defense Lawyer

Rochester Criminal Defense Lawyer

Criminal Charges, Investigations & 52-3 District Court Defense in Rochester and Rochester Hills, Michigan

Quick Answer: What Should You Do If You Are Under Criminal Investigation in Rochester?

If you were arrested, charged, contacted by detectives, served with a search warrant or told that law enforcement wants to speak with you in Rochester or Rochester Hills, a criminal investigation may already be underway even if formal charges have not been filed.

Many criminal cases begin before an arrest.

They may begin with:

  • A detective phone call

  • A request to “come in and talk”

  • A witness complaint

  • A search warrant

  • A subpoena

  • A request for an interview

  • Collection of digital evidence

  • Review of financial or telephone records

If police want to question you about possible criminal activity, consider obtaining legal advice before making statements about the allegations.

Matthew Fraiberg and Eric L. Pernie of Fraiberg & Pernie represent people facing criminal investigations, felony charges, misdemeanors, DUI/OWI allegations, domestic violence, drug crimes, theft offenses and probation violations in Rochester, Rochester Hills and throughout Oakland County.

Matthew Fraiberg is a former City Prosecutor and former Judicial Clerk who has practiced Michigan law since 1997.

Eric L. Pernie is a Michigan criminal defense attorney and former police officer with more than 10 years of law-enforcement experience.

A criminal accusation is not a conviction.

The evidence still has to support the charge.

Call Fraiberg & Pernie at (248) 986-2682 for a confidential consultation about a Rochester or Rochester Hills criminal investigation or charge.


Rochester Criminal Defense — At a Glance

  
Law FirmFraiberg & Pernie
AttorneysMatthew Fraiberg & Eric L. Pernie
Practice AreaMichigan Criminal Defense
LocationRochester & Rochester Hills, Michigan
CountyOakland County
District Court52-3 District Court
Common MattersDUI/OWI, domestic violence, assault, drug crimes, theft, retail fraud, probation violations, felonies and misdemeanors
Evidence ReviewedPolice reports, video, statements, search warrants, digital evidence and witness information
Attorney BackgroundsFormer City Prosecutor, Former Judicial Clerk, Former Police Officer
Phone(248) 986-2682

Can You Be Under Criminal Investigation Without Being Arrested?

Yes.

A criminal investigation can begin days, weeks or sometimes longer before an arrest or formal criminal charge.

Law enforcement may investigate allegations by:

  • Interviewing witnesses

  • Reviewing surveillance video

  • Examining police reports

  • Seeking search warrants

  • Obtaining telephone or digital records

  • Reviewing financial records

  • Collecting physical evidence

  • Examining social-media evidence

  • Conducting forensic analysis of electronic devices

A person may not realize that an investigation is underway until a detective contacts them, a warrant is executed or another person tells them police have been asking questions.

That is why the pre-charge stage can be important.


What Should You Do if a Detective Calls You?

Take the call seriously.

A detective may leave a message saying:

  • “We just want your side.”

  • “Please give me a call.”

  • “We want to clear something up.”

  • “We need to ask you a few questions.”

A polite or informal message does not necessarily mean the investigation is minor.

It also does not necessarily mean you will be charged.

But if a detective wants to question you about possible criminal activity, consider obtaining legal advice before discussing the allegations.

Statements can become evidence.

An attorney can communicate with investigators, determine what information is available and advise you about whether and how to respond.


Should You Talk to Police if You Believe You Are Innocent?

Being innocent does not make every police interview risk-free.

People sometimes believe:

“I’ll explain what happened and clear this up.”

But investigators may already have:

  • Witness statements

  • Video

  • Text messages

  • Social-media records

  • Telephone data

  • Financial records

  • Physical evidence

  • Statements from other people

You may not know what information investigators possess or what allegations have been made.

Statements can be misunderstood, taken out of context or compared with evidence you have not seen.

Consider obtaining legal advice before answering investigative questions.


What Should You Do During the First Week of a Criminal Investigation?

The appropriate steps depend on the circumstances, but potential priorities include:

  • Preserving evidence

  • Keeping relevant communications

  • Identifying potential witnesses

  • Preserving photographs or video

  • Reviewing available documents

  • Evaluating search warrants

  • Reviewing court records

  • Avoiding unnecessary statements

  • Avoiding contact that could create additional allegations

  • Obtaining legal advice

Do not destroy, delete, hide or alter potential evidence.

Deleting text messages, emails, photographs, social-media information or other evidence after learning of an investigation can create additional legal problems.


What Evidence Is Used in Rochester Criminal Investigations?

Modern criminal investigations can involve many different forms of evidence.

Depending on the allegation, evidence may include:

  • Police reports

  • Body-camera footage

  • Dash-camera footage

  • Surveillance video

  • 911 recordings

  • Witness statements

  • Search-warrant materials

  • Phone records

  • Text messages

  • Emails

  • Social-media evidence

  • GPS or location information

  • Financial records

  • Photographs

  • Medical records

  • Forensic downloads

  • Physical evidence

The defense should evaluate the evidence itself rather than relying solely on conclusions contained in a police report.


Why Digital Evidence Matters in Modern Criminal Cases

Digital evidence has become increasingly important in criminal investigations.

Potential sources include:

  • Cell phones

  • Text messages

  • Email accounts

  • Social-media accounts

  • Surveillance systems

  • GPS information

  • Cloud storage

  • Financial accounts

  • Electronic payment records

  • Internet records

Digital evidence may support an allegation.

It may also provide context, establish a timeline, contradict a witness or identify information favorable to the defense.

The significance depends on what the evidence actually shows and whether it was lawfully obtained.


Can Police Search Your Phone?

Not automatically.

The legality of a phone search depends on the circumstances.

Issues can include:

  • Consent

  • Search warrants

  • Scope of the warrant

  • Probable cause

  • Particularity of the warrant

  • How the search was conducted

  • What data was actually obtained

Modern phones can contain enormous amounts of personal information.

When electronic evidence becomes important to a criminal case, the authority for obtaining and searching that evidence should be evaluated.


What Happens if Police Execute a Search Warrant?

A search warrant generally authorizes law enforcement to search the location, property or data described in the warrant within its lawful scope.

After executing a warrant, investigators may:

  • Seize physical evidence

  • Seize electronic devices

  • Photograph the location

  • Interview people

  • Analyze seized evidence

  • Conduct forensic examinations

  • Submit evidence for laboratory testing

  • Continue interviewing witnesses

  • Present information to a prosecutor

A search warrant does not automatically mean criminal charges will be filed.

The investigation may continue after the search.

The warrant, supporting legal process and manner in which the search was conducted may become important to the defense.


What Should You Do After Police Execute a Search Warrant?

Consider:

  • Preserving the warrant and inventory paperwork

  • Writing down what occurred

  • Identifying what was seized

  • Preserving relevant video or photographs

  • Avoiding unnecessary discussions about the allegations

  • Avoiding deletion or alteration of electronic information

  • Obtaining legal advice

Do not interfere physically with officers executing a warrant.

Questions concerning the legality or scope of the search can be addressed through the legal process.


Can a Lawyer Help Before Criminal Charges Are Filed?

Yes.

A criminal defense attorney does not necessarily have to wait until an arrest or formal charge.

Depending on the circumstances, pre-charge representation may involve:

  • Communicating with investigators

  • Advising the client about interview requests

  • Preserving evidence

  • Identifying witnesses

  • Reviewing available records

  • Evaluating search warrants

  • Determining whether a court case has been filed

  • Preparing for possible charges

  • Addressing surrender arrangements when appropriate

No attorney can guarantee that early representation will prevent charges.

But obtaining advice before making important decisions can help a person understand the investigation and avoid unnecessary mistakes.


Can You Be Charged Without Being Arrested First?

Yes.

Police do not always make an immediate arrest.

An investigation may be submitted to a prosecutor, and criminal charges can potentially be authorized later.

Depending on the circumstances, a person may then:

  • Receive notice to appear

  • Be arraigned

  • Be asked to surrender

  • Be arrested on a warrant

The procedure depends on the allegation and case.


What Happens After Criminal Charges Are Filed?

The procedure depends on whether the allegation is a misdemeanor or felony.

Potential stages can include:

  • Arraignment

  • Bond

  • Discovery

  • Pretrial proceedings

  • Motion practice

  • Negotiations

  • Preliminary examination in felony matters

  • Circuit Court proceedings in felony cases

  • Plea

  • Trial

  • Sentencing following conviction

Not every case proceeds through every stage.


What Happens at Arraignment?

Arraignment is generally an early formal court proceeding.

The court may address:

  • The criminal charge

  • Applicable rights

  • Bond

  • Conditions of release

  • No-contact provisions

  • Travel restrictions

  • Testing requirements when applicable

  • Future court dates

The specific conditions depend on the allegations, record and circumstances.

Follow all written bond conditions unless and until the court modifies them.


What Court Handles Rochester and Rochester Hills Criminal Cases?

Criminal cases arising in Rochester and Rochester Hills may involve the 52-3 District Court in Rochester Hills, depending on the offense and jurisdiction.

District Courts generally handle misdemeanor cases and the initial stages of felony cases.

Felony matters that proceed beyond the District Court stage can move to Oakland County Circuit Court.

Court assignment matters because the location of the alleged offense determines where a criminal case is generally filed.


Why Does the 52-3 District Court Matter?

For a case assigned to the 52-3 District Court, the defense should understand:

  • Court scheduling

  • Filing requirements

  • Bond conditions

  • Pretrial procedures

  • Discovery

  • Motion deadlines

  • Felony preliminary proceedings when applicable

  • Local administrative practices

Familiarity with a court’s procedures can help an attorney and client prepare appropriately.

Prior experience in a particular court does not guarantee a particular result.


What Criminal Charges Does Fraiberg & Pernie Defend in Rochester?

Fraiberg & Pernie represents clients facing a range of Michigan criminal allegations.

These include:

The appropriate defense depends on the specific allegation and evidence.


Rochester DUI & OWI Defense

DUI and OWI cases often begin with a traffic stop rather than a traditional criminal investigation.

Potential evidence includes:

  • Driving observations

  • Body-camera video

  • Dash-camera video

  • Field sobriety tests

  • Breath testing

  • Blood testing

  • Police reports

  • Statements

Fraiberg & Pernie represents clients facing first-offense OWI, High BAC, repeat OWI, felony OWI, drugged driving and implied-consent issues.

Learn more about Michigan DUI and OWI defense.


Rochester Domestic Violence Defense

Domestic violence allegations can develop quickly.

Police may rely on:

  • Statements

  • 911 calls

  • Body-camera footage

  • Photographs

  • Medical evidence

  • Text messages

  • Witness accounts

  • Prior relationship information

Bond conditions may also restrict contact between the accused person and another individual.

Learn more about Michigan domestic violence defense.


Rochester Drug Crime Defense

Drug investigations can involve:

  • Traffic stops

  • Search warrants

  • Vehicle searches

  • Home searches

  • Informants

  • Surveillance

  • Phone evidence

  • Laboratory testing

  • Statements

Potential defense issues can include possession, knowledge, search and seizure, identification of the substance and admissibility of evidence.

Learn more about Michigan controlled-substance charges.


Rochester Theft, Retail Fraud & Fraud Defense

Theft and fraud investigations can involve:

  • Surveillance video

  • Financial records

  • Receipts

  • Electronic transactions

  • Witness statements

  • Employee records

  • Text messages

  • Emails

  • Other digital evidence

The evidence necessary to defend a case depends on the particular offense.

Learn more about Michigan retail fraud defense.


Can Rochester Criminal Charges Be Reduced?

Sometimes.

A negotiated reduction may depend on:

  • Strength of the evidence

  • Criminal history

  • Evidentiary issues

  • Constitutional issues

  • Witness problems

  • Mitigating circumstances

  • Prosecutor

  • Charge

  • Court

  • Negotiations

No attorney can responsibly guarantee a reduction.


Can Rochester Criminal Charges Be Dismissed?

Potentially.

Dismissal depends on the evidence and applicable law.

Issues can include:

  • Unlawful searches

  • Unlawful seizures

  • Improperly obtained statements

  • Insufficient evidence

  • Witness credibility

  • Missing evidence

  • Identification problems

  • Search-warrant issues

  • Constitutional violations

  • Failure to prove an essential element

An arrest or accusation does not establish guilt.

The prosecution still must prove the charged offense.

Prospective clients can review Fraiberg & Pernie’s Michigan criminal defense case results.

Past results do not guarantee or predict the outcome of another case.


What Does a Criminal Defense Lawyer Review?

The evidence depends on the case, but a defense investigation may involve:

  • Police reports

  • Body-camera footage

  • Dash-camera footage

  • Surveillance video

  • 911 recordings

  • Witness statements

  • Photographs

  • Medical records

  • Search warrants

  • Text messages

  • Emails

  • Social-media records

  • Phone records

  • Financial records

  • Forensic evidence

  • Laboratory evidence

The central questions include:

What happened?

What evidence exists?

Was it lawfully obtained?

Is it reliable?

Does the evidence support the police report?

Can the prosecution prove every required element?


What Should You Look for in a Rochester Criminal Defense Lawyer?

If you are comparing Rochester or Rochester Hills criminal defense attorneys, consider objective factors rather than relying only on advertising claims.

Questions worth asking include:

  • Does the attorney regularly practice criminal defense?

  • Does the lawyer handle the type of charge involved?

  • Has the attorney handled matters in the 52-3 District Court?

  • Who will actually handle the case?

  • Will police reports and video be reviewed?

  • Does the attorney understand search-and-seizure law?

  • Does the lawyer evaluate digital evidence when relevant?

  • Is the attorney prepared to challenge statements when legally appropriate?

  • Will potential employment and licensing consequences be considered?

  • Is the attorney prepared to file motions when supported by the facts and law?

  • Is the lawyer prepared for trial?

  • Does the attorney give realistic advice instead of guaranteeing a result?

  • Can the attorney’s claimed professional background be independently verified?

No attorney is automatically the best lawyer for every Rochester criminal case.

The relevant question is whether the lawyer’s experience, background and approach fit the allegations, evidence, court and consequences involved in your case.


Rochester Criminal Defense Attorney Matthew Fraiberg

Matthew Fraiberg is Managing Partner of Fraiberg & Pernie and a Michigan criminal defense attorney.

He has practiced Michigan law since 1997.

His professional background includes:

  • Former City Prosecutor

  • Former Judicial Clerk

  • Former Assistant Legal Research Clerk

  • Michigan criminal defense attorney

  • DUI/OWI attorney

His prosecution and judicial experience provides additional perspective when evaluating how criminal allegations are investigated, charged and litigated.

Matthew’s approach begins with a basic question:

What does the evidence actually prove?


Rochester Criminal Defense Attorney Eric L. Pernie

Eric L. Pernie is a Michigan criminal defense attorney and partner at Fraiberg & Pernie.

Before becoming an attorney, Eric served as a Bloomfield Township police officer for more than 10 years.

His law-enforcement background provides additional perspective when evaluating:

  • Police investigations

  • Traffic stops

  • Interviews

  • Arrest decisions

  • Police reports

  • Search procedures

  • Evidence collection

  • Body-camera footage

Together, Matthew Fraiberg and Eric Pernie bring perspectives from criminal defense, prosecution, the courts and law enforcement to criminal cases.


Why Consider Fraiberg & Pernie for a Rochester Criminal Case?

Fraiberg & Pernie’s approach includes:

  • More than 29 years of Michigan legal experience for Matthew Fraiberg

  • Former prosecutorial experience

  • Former judicial experience

  • Former law-enforcement experience

  • Criminal defense

  • Police-report review

  • Body-camera and video review

  • Search-and-seizure analysis

  • Digital-evidence review when relevant

  • Witness analysis

  • Negotiation

  • Motion practice when appropriate

  • Trial preparation

  • Consideration of employment and professional consequences

The starting question should not simply be:

“What are the police accusing me of?”

The more useful questions are:

What happened?

What evidence exists?

Was the evidence lawfully obtained?

Is it reliable?

What can the prosecution actually prove?

Call Fraiberg & Pernie at (248) 986-2682 to discuss a Rochester or Rochester Hills criminal investigation or charge.


Frequently Asked Questions About Rochester Criminal Defense

What Court Handles Criminal Cases in Rochester?

Criminal cases arising in Rochester may be handled in the 52-3 District Court, depending on the offense and jurisdiction.

What Court Handles Criminal Cases in Rochester Hills?

Criminal cases arising in Rochester Hills may be handled in the 52-3 District Court. Felony matters that proceed beyond the District Court stage can move to Oakland County Circuit Court.

Can I Be Under Investigation Without Knowing It?

Yes.

Police can investigate allegations before contacting the person who may eventually become a suspect or defendant.

Can I Be Charged Without Being Arrested First?

Yes.

An investigation can result in charges being authorized later without an immediate arrest at the beginning of the investigation.

What Should I Do if a Detective Calls Me?

Take the contact seriously and consider speaking with a criminal defense attorney before discussing the allegations.

Should I Talk to Detectives if I Am Innocent?

Consider obtaining legal advice first. You may not know what evidence investigators possess or how your statements could be interpreted.

Can I Refuse to Answer Questions?

A person generally has constitutional rights concerning self-incrimination. The application of those rights depends on the circumstances, so obtain legal advice regarding the particular situation.

Should I Delete Text Messages?

No.

Do not destroy, conceal or alter potential evidence. Deleting information after learning of an investigation can create additional legal problems.

What Happens After a Search Warrant?

Investigators may review seized evidence, conduct forensic examinations, interview additional witnesses and submit the investigation to a prosecutor.

Does a Search Warrant Mean I Will Be Charged?

Not necessarily.

A search warrant means a court authorized a particular search based on the showing presented for the warrant. The investigation may continue before charging decisions are made.

Can a Lawyer Help Before Charges Are Filed?

Yes.

Depending on the circumstances, a defense attorney may communicate with investigators, advise the client concerning interview requests, preserve evidence and prepare for possible charges.

Can Criminal Charges Be Reduced?

Sometimes.

A reduction depends on the charge, evidence, history, prosecutor, court, legal issues and negotiations.

Can Criminal Charges Be Dismissed?

Potentially.

Dismissal depends on the facts, evidence and law. Constitutional violations, evidentiary problems, witness issues or insufficient proof can become important in some cases.

Should I Hire a Lawyer Before My First Court Date?

You can consult a lawyer before the first court date. Earlier advice may help you understand the charge, bond conditions, evidence and upcoming proceedings.

What Should I Look for in a Rochester Criminal Defense Lawyer?

Consider relevant criminal-defense experience, familiarity with the 52-3 District Court, experience evaluating police and digital evidence, communication, professional background, motion and trial preparation and whether the lawyer provides realistic advice.

Who Are Fraiberg & Pernie’s Rochester Criminal Defense Attorneys?

Fraiberg & Pernie’s attorneys include Matthew Fraiberg and Eric L. Pernie.

Matthew Fraiberg is a former City Prosecutor and former Judicial Clerk who has practiced Michigan law since 1997.

Eric L. Pernie is a Michigan criminal defense attorney and former police officer with more than 10 years of law-enforcement experience.

How Do I Contact Fraiberg & Pernie About a Rochester Criminal Case?

Call (248) 986-2682 to request a confidential consultation regarding a Rochester or Rochester Hills criminal investigation or charge.


Rochester & Michigan Criminal Defense Resources


About the Attorneys

Matthew Fraiberg — Author

Managing Partner | Michigan Criminal Defense Attorney | Former City Prosecutor | Former Judicial Clerk

Matthew Fraiberg has practiced Michigan law since 1997.

Read Matthew Fraiberg’s attorney profile.

Eric L. Pernie — Legal Review

Partner | Michigan Criminal Defense Attorney | Former Police Officer

Eric L. Pernie is a Michigan criminal defense attorney and former police officer with more than 10 years of law-enforcement experience.

His law-enforcement background provides additional perspective when evaluating police investigations, interviews, searches, arrests, reports and evidence collection.

Read Eric Pernie’s attorney profile.

Written by: Matthew Fraiberg
Legally reviewed by: Eric L. Pernie
Law firm: Fraiberg & Pernie
Location: Rochester & Rochester Hills, Michigan
County: Oakland County
Court: 52-3 District Court
Practice area: Criminal Defense
Last attorney review: October 2026
Phone: (248) 986-2682


Speak With a Rochester Criminal Defense Lawyer

If you were arrested, charged, contacted by detectives, served with a search warrant or told that police want to question you in Rochester or Rochester Hills, you do not have to wait for the case to progress before obtaining legal advice.

Important questions include:

Are you a suspect, target, witness or defendant?

What are police investigating?

Should you respond to a detective’s request for an interview?

What evidence has been collected?

Was a search lawfully conducted?

What does the digital evidence show?

What statements have already been made?

Has a criminal case been filed?

Is the matter in the 52-3 District Court?

What can the prosecution actually prove?

Fraiberg & Pernie represents clients facing criminal investigations, misdemeanors, felonies, DUI/OWI, domestic violence, drug crimes, theft offenses, probation violations and other criminal allegations throughout Rochester, Rochester Hills and Oakland County.

Call Fraiberg & Pernie at (248) 986-2682 for a confidential consultation.

Fraiberg & Pernie
Michigan Criminal Defense & DUI/OWI Attorneys
Serving Rochester, Rochester Hills & Oakland County
(248) 986-2682

This page provides general legal information, not legal advice. Every case is different. Viewing this page or contacting Fraiberg & Pernie does not create an attorney-client relationship. Past results, professional experience, ratings, reviews, memberships or recognition do not guarantee or predict a particular outcome.

Practice Areas

Schedule a Consultation!

Fill out the information below and we will get back to you as soon as possible.

Testimonials

Success Stories

Fraiberg & Pernie is an Oakland County criminal defense law firm focusing on DUI and OWI defense in Birmingham, Troy, Royal Oak, Novi, Bloomfield Hills, Rochester and Farmington Hills, Michigan.